
Citadel’s latest production, A Jukebox for the Algonquin, truly captured my heart. It’s a refreshing reminder that as we age, life doesn’t lose its spark—it merely shifts to a new rhythm, one filled with laughter, camaraderie, and unexpected joys. This delightful offering beautifully showcased the vibrant lives that still await us in our twilight years, proving that fun and bond know no age limit.
Radiating vibrancy and warmth, this production showcases the spirited lives of its characters who discover purpose and happiness in life’s simplest yet most impactful moments. More than just a theatrical presentation, it’s a heartfelt and uplifting depiction of aging with grace, infused with humor and emotional depth.
Paul Stroili's A Jukebox for the Algonquin stands out as a true treasure of the stage, effortlessly blending sharp humor with heartfelt emotion in a celebration of the intricate tapestry of life. Transporting audiences to the delightful Placid Pines Senior Care Center in upstate New York, this play radiates with originality and charm. It introduces us to a spirited ensemble of senior residents who, driven by a nostalgic longing for their youth, devise an unexpectedly daring scheme to fund their dream of owning a jukebox—by selling marijuana. Yep! And let’s just say that the journey is as wildly entertaining as it is endearing.
The jukebox emerges as a powerful symbol, resonating far beyond this specific story. It reflects a hope from the struggles of many residents who, isolated and yearning for connection, are left grappling with a lack of stimulation, music, and activities. These individuals are confined to neglected, unrenovated sections of sprawling senior complexes, spaces that corporate priorities have relegated to the margins. This pattern has become disturbingly prevalent, as corporate-driven changes focus on enhancing facilities for wealthier, younger seniors, while leaving lower-income, older residents behind. At Placid Pines, this disparity is starkly evident: the entertainment room offers little more than a fish tank with dying fish and shelves stocked with donated books—the heartfelt contribution of a single paralyzed resident, whose spirit reflects the quiet resilience of the overlooked community.
With vividly drawn characters, sharp and vibrant dialogue, and deeply touching moments, Stroili explores themes of enduring friendship, unwavering resilience, and the determination to transcend the boundaries of age. The play shines in its remarkable ability to uncover life’s beauty and humor in the most unexpected places. The camaraderie and ingenuity of the residents will have you laughing out loud, shedding a tear, and cheering them on throughout their unforgettable adventure.
Helmed by Director Scott Westerman, this Chicago Theatre debut is sure to touch your heart. Set within the lively recreation room of the Placid Pines Senior Care Center, this production sparkles with energy and charm, brought to life by a vibrant cast of residents, each with personalities as dynamic as the tunes on a jukebox. Leading the charge is Kenneth Johnson as Johnny, an exuberant Yankees enthusiast and the driving force behind the gang’s mission to acquire a jukebox. Johnson’s effervescent energy and magnetic stage presence make Johnny both endearing and immensely enjoyable to watch.
Adding depth and balance to the production is Bob Sanders in the role of Dennis, Johnny’s steadfast best friend and the voice of reason amidst the group’s lively escapades. Sanders delivers a warm and nuanced performance, anchoring their dynamic with sincerity and poise. Ellen Phelps lights up the stage as Annie, her lively and animated personality adding flair and excitement to every scene she graces. Elizabeth Rude completes this delightful ensemble as Peg, capturing the role with subtle charm and a compelling presence. Together, these four seasoned actors weave a narrative rich in humor, camaraderie, and heart, crafting a performance that is simply captivating.
Bringing a humorous twist to the story is Patrick Thornton as Chuck, the janitor affectionately referred to as the “dust mop guy.” Thornton’s charismatic and witty portrayal adds moments of lighthearted fun that resonate effortlessly with the audience. Rounding out this exceptional cast are Karla Corona and Joshua Thomas, who embody Placid Pines staff members with finesse, seamlessly bridging the interactions between the spirited residents and enriching the production with their well-rounded performances.
This ensemble delivers a performance that is not just entertaining but genuinely heartwarming, showcasing a narrative filled with humor, passion, and a sense of community. With their skillful portrayals, they transform the recreation room of Placid Pines into a vibrant stage where laughter, drama, and connection take center stage.
I found it especially moving how the production cleverly employed the jukebox as a symbol for life’s playlist. Much like the selections we make on a jukebox, we can choose our moments, embrace our decisions, and immerse ourselves in the harmonies of both our past and present. Citadel has masterfully created a work that strikes a chord, offering the audience a fresh perspective on the richness of life’s adventures and the bonds that can thrive in its later chapters.
A Jukebox for the Algonquin is a touching tribute to friendship, community, and the timeless spark that fuels our lives, no matter our age. It beautifully prompted me to reflect on the richness of life’s later chapters, highlighting the joy of embracing them with curiosity and a zest for living. This production is an absolute delight and a perfect pick for anyone in search of inspiration and heartwarming entertainment.
Currently being performed at the Citadel Theatre in Lake Forest, this production is a must-see for theater enthusiasts. The Citadel Theatre's intimate setting and exceptional cast bring Stroili's vision to life, making A Jukebox for the Algonquin an unforgettable theatrical experience. It’s not just theater—it’s a triumph. This joyous and moving exploration of life’s complexities leaves audiences with a renewed appreciation for the enduring vibrancy of the human spirit. What an absolutely wonderful play!
Performance Schedule: April 18 – May 18, 2025
Newly Added Dates:
For tickets and/or show information, click here.
*Extended through May 25th
*This review is also featured on https://www.theatreinchicago.com/!
It must have been heavenly for the creative leaders of Goodman, Steppenwolf, Chicago Shakespeare and Court, Chicago’s top regional theaters,…
Come From Away begins from a place of deep uncertainty, yet what emerges is a story grounded in the steady,…
Steppenwolf Theatre Company, the nation's premier ensemble theater company, is pleased to launch its 51st Season with Suzan-Lori Parks' Pulitzer Prize-winning drama Topdog/Underdog, helmed by Tony Award-winning…
The first thing you notice about the meticulously curated Black dance performance held at the Harris Theater over the weekend…
Vape! The Grease Parody, currently running at Chicago’s Apollo Theater through January, takes a satirical swing at the iconic 1978…
BrightSide Theatre will celebrate its 15th anniversary with "Monte Carlo Night," a gala and fundraiser, on Friday, September 25, 2026,…
Giordano Dance Chicago (GDC) hosts its highly anticipated 19th Anniversary "Dancing With The Giordano Stars" ballroom dance competition 7-11 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 8…
Hell in a Handbag Productions celebrates its 25th year with a revival of Joan Crawford Goes to Hell, a sharp,…
Composition, tension, balance, light, and harmony come together seamlessly in Kokandy Productions’ revival of Sondheim’s opus, ‘Sunday in the Park…
Award-winning Redtwist Theatre, launching its 22nd season with Prayer Circle, September 17 - November 8, by Erik Gernand and directed by Executive Artistic Director Dusty Brown, announces today…
Buffalo Theatre Ensemble (BTE), the professional theater company in residence at the McAninch Arts Center (MAC), is pleased to announce that, in keeping…
Promethean Theatre Ensemble announced today it will offer post-show audience talkbacks following two performances of their Chicago premiere of BLOOD OF…
City Lit Theatre’s world premiere of Shane, adapted for the stage and directed by Mark Pracht, brings a fresh, nostalgic…
The rise of artificial intelligence raises many questions about its effect on humanity. What does it mean if we become…
Drury Lane Theatre opens its latest musical with a warm jolt of rock ’n’ roll energy as Buddy – The…
Broadway In Chicago is pleased to announce a darkly delicious Halloween surprise: Kokandy Productions’ critically acclaimed revival of JEKYLL & HYDE will be extended…
Chicago-based Emmy Award-winning performance collective and film/video production company Manual Cinema premiered two new hand-animated films at the Obama Presidential Center Museum…
If you need an energy boost, skip the can of Monster and get yourself, plus loved ones of any age,…
Victory Gardens Theater (2433 N. Lincoln Avenue), an historic incubator for new play development, proudly announces the World Premiere staging of The…
Joining the previously announced stars of Kowalski Johnny Galecki ("The Big Bang Theory," "The Little Dog Laughed") as Tennessee Williams and Jacob Moskovitz ("Elle") as Marlon…
Shattered Globe Theatre is pleased to open its 36th Season with the Midwest premiere of Erika Sheffer's Vladimir, an unflinching drama of resistance directed by Ensemble Member Lou Contey*,…
The League of Chicago Theatres announces the return of Tickets for a 20. From Thursday, August 27 through Monday, September 14, 2026, theatregoers can…
Babes With Blades Theatre Company’s (BWBTC), now presenting the world premiere of yo ho. through August 29 at The Edge Off-Broadway, shares the…
BrightSide Theatre has announced cast and crew for THE ADDAMS FAMILY MUSICAL - the kickoff production of BrightSide's 15th Anniversary season.…
From its beginning in 1992 on the tiny stage of a modest theater, Dance for Life (DFL) has grown and…
Chicago Shakespeare Theater (CST) announces the cast and creative team for the company's fall Shakespeare Repertory productions, an unforgettable theatrical event at the heart…
Rising star Jacob Moskovitz ("Elle") has joined the cast of Kowalski as Marlon Brando, alongside previously announced Chicago theater veteran Johnny Galecki ("The Big Bang Theory," "The Little…
There was a particular kind of magic to seeing a movie outside when I was a kid in 1970s Chicago…
Perhaps surprisingly, Anatomy of a Suicide is not an overwhelmingly emotionally gripping play, nor is it horrifying. Instead, it vividly…
This narrative tracks five individuals within the "People’s Diasporatic Party"—outfitted in corporate attire—as they take refuge in a desolate East…
Standing Room Only Crowd for Chicago’s Leading Theater Artistic Directors
The Best of Us: Marriott Theatre’s Come From Away
Steppenwolf Theatre Presents Revival of TOPDOG/UNDERDOG September 17 – November 1 / Rehearsals Underway
Chicago Black Dance Legacy Project Gala: Radiant & Sumptuous at the Harris
Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.